People often say if it’s worth reading by other folks, it’s worth writing yourself. I think they’re right. A clean sentence is easy to get from AI. What makes me want to keep reading is finding out what someone saw that I would have missed.
Ask AI to write about a neighbourhood shop closing and it can give you a competent paragraph about a local institution. Ask someone who went there every week and they might tell you the owner kept a spare pair of reading glasses by the till for customers who forgot theirs. I’d read another page about that shop.
A few years ago, I wrote about what we lose when we stop reading long-form prose. Part of the pleasure of reading an essay slowly is spending time with someone else’s way of paying attention. The detail they dwell on might be the one you’d have skipped. By the end, you might care about something you barely thought about when you started.
Writing asks you to pay that kind of attention yourself. Say you’re writing about why a project ran late. You start with We needed more time. Then you look at what happened and realise that everyone knew the deadline was slipping two weeks before anyone told the client. Suddenly you’re writing about why nobody wanted to make that call. That’s a harder thing to write and a far more useful thing to know.
Sam Halpert made much the same point about education. Imagine bringing a forklift to the gym. You can move every weight in the room and leave without doing a single rep. A student who writes an essay gets to practise making a claim and finding out whether it holds up.
“The work is what happens within you.”
I’m happy to use AI to pull action items from a meeting transcript or point out where a paragraph is hard to follow. With an essay, I’d rather do enough of the writing to find the sentence I wouldn’t have known to ask for. Sometimes that’s the one I end up building the whole piece around.
Cover photo by Mike Murray on Pexels.